Labour still can't do basic maths

 In an interview on Sunday 15th Nov Pat McFadden said "rejoining the EU would be worth 0.4% of GDP in the long term." He went on to say "that is a great deal of money" ie he didn't know what the number would be.

I will do the difficult maths for him.

The GDP of the United's Kingdom is about £3 Trillion so 0.4% is £12 Billion....in the long term it would be a £12Billion gain.

Now rejoining would cost £750 Million per week. Again difficult maths. That's £39 Billion per year.

Again this is difficult maths but £12 Billion is less than £39 Billion.

Add on the fact the Labour have given the EU £21 Billion, I struggle to see how they think the EU is worth it....

In 2018 the UK exported £303 Billion but imported £357 Billion from the EU.  The EU were net winners.

Compare that to today now we have left the EU we export £350 Billion but import a whopping £485 Billion. 

Clearly leaving the EU has done little to stop the supply of goods from the EU into the UK. Exports to the EU since 2019 have pretty much kept pace with inflation so leaving has very little impact.  

So either Britain is either 1/ terrible at exporting to the EU 2/ the EU doesnt want what we have 3/ the EU is biased against the UK and deliberately doesnt buy our stuff

I suspect 3/ is a key reason.  When we were still in the EU I did some analysis and it suggested EU government procurement was extremely biased to local suppliers whilst the UK government procurement was not and seemed to actually favour EU supplier over our own.  

So why rejoin?  It would simply open the floodgates to yet more imports from the EU, when movement of goods becomes easier,  which is unlikely to benefit the UK economy. It's exports of our products which generate wealth for the UK - not imports.

Maybe Labour would like to post a comment explaining their maths logic on why the EU is such a good idea.

==========================================

17th Nov

Well showman Barnum at the Lord Mayor's Banquet last night in his speech said "the UK has lost more than we have gained [as a result of leaving the EU]".  Not really true.  For a start Barnum on the 26th Oct - literally only a few weeks before, said "Britain is the fastest growing economy in the G7". There are only 3 EU countries in the G7: France, Germany, and Italy. So Britain is growing faster than the 2 main countries keeping the EU alive.  The week before this Barnum said at Prime Minister's question time "[Britain is] the standout nation for deficit reduction and the joint fastest growing country in the G7".

So what is it - we are losers because of Brexit or we're the best performing?  Both statements can't be true. 

In 2025 the UK economy grew 1.2% whilst France grew 0.8% and Germany just 0.2%.  

Contribution to the EU are based on GDP so if our economy continues to grow faster then we would pay more for EU membership - Germany, with their stagnant growth, proportionally will pay less.

So back to Barnum's story ""the UK has lost more than we have gained".

Our exports to the EU have grown since we left - they have roughly kept pace with inflation.  Exports from the EU to the UK have however ballooned. I therefore think the truthful statement is "the EU gained far more from Brexit than we have". I think that says more about the weak negotiation of the UK than EU.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Energy Performance of Privately Rent Properties - expect crazy things as we approach 2028

It's fair to tax landlords and dividend income like workers [the gospel according to Rachel]

Rachel planning to charge National Insurance on rental income